At Cheltenham on Friday, 23 October, East India Express was beaten a short head.
He had been off the track for 187 days and he drifted badly on the day, out from 13.5 to an Exchange starting price of 18.27. None of that mattered once the race was run. He got the perfect trip, he got a lovely jump at the last because the hurdle had been flattened, he hit the front, and he traded at 1.05 in running. At 1.05 the market has already paid the race out. Frontier Prince got back up on the bob. A stride earlier or a stride later and we win it.

Another second. And that is the one that started this piece off, because once you have had a day like that you go back through the book and start counting the rest of them. There are quite a lot.
So here are some of them. Not the lot, just the ones that still hurt: horses we have put up since Royal Ascot that have been beaten into 2nd, how they got beaten, and how short they went while they were getting beaten. Every grid below is the result as it appears on our own racecards.
There is no spin in it. A second pays nothing. But the in-running prices are worth your time, because they are the part of the record that tells you whether the analysis had you on the right horse in the right race, even on the days the result went against us.
Since Royal Ascot we have been beaten into 2nd more times than we want to count. Of the ones we have been back through, 19 were odds-on in running and 7 were beaten by a nose or a short head.
How frustrating is this?
Beaten at 1.01, and we do not think it was real
On 24 October at Cheltenham, Road To Wembley traded at 1.01 in running in a novices' hurdle. At 1.01 the market is saying the race is over: roughly a 99 in 100 chance, with money still being matched. He was then beaten 2 and a quarter lengths by Woodstock Octo.

Here is the thing, though. We do not believe that price. Road To Wembley should never have traded 1.01 in that race, and our read is that somebody had the 2 of them round the wrong way.
Look at the colours in the grid above. Woodstock Octo is the dark jacket with red diamonds and a red cap. Road To Wembley is the plain red jacket, also with a red cap. At racing speed, head on, those 2 are very easy to mix up, and we think that is exactly what happened: the horse that was actually winning got matched as the wrong one. We cannot prove it and we are not totally sure what went on, but a horse does not trade 1.01 and then get beaten 2 and a quarter lengths without something being off.
So we will not claim that one as a near miss. The genuine ones are below, and there are plenty of them. Start with the week it all began.
Royal Ascot: 10 seconds in 5 days
Royal Ascot was where it began. We came out of the meeting with 10 horses beaten into 2nd, 8 of them odds-on in running, and 7 of the 10 beaten half a length or less. Added together, the whole week cost us about 3 and a half lengths.
Biggest price first, because that is the part the market got wrong. Three of them were double figures on the Exchange and still ended up odds-on in running.
Elarak, the Buckingham Palace Stakes
An Exchange SP of 21.00, traded down to 1.30 in running, then beaten 0.3 lengths by Mezcala in a field of 32.

Al Azd, the King George V Stakes
An Exchange SP of 19.54, traded down to 1.56 in running, then beaten 0.5 lengths by Enceladus in a field of 22.

French Master, the Queen Alexandra Stakes
An Exchange SP of 15.70, traded down to 1.04 in running, then beaten 0.3 lengths by Illinois in a field of 13.

Gamrai, the Copper Horse Stakes
An Exchange SP of 6.90, traded down to 1.61 in running, then beaten 0.2 lengths by Daiquiri Bay in a field of 19.

Trawlerman, the Gold Cup
An Exchange SP of 4.60, traded down to 1.27 in running, then beaten 0.2 lengths by Scandinavia in a field of 11.

Gstaad, the St James's Palace Stakes, a Group 1
An Exchange SP of 3.48, traded down to 1.67 in running, then beaten 0.1 lengths by Bow Echo in a field of 6.

Satono Reve, the Queen Elizabeth II Jubilee Stakes, a Group 1 sprint
An Exchange SP of 3.39, traded down to 2.50 in running, then beaten a nose, 0.05 lengths by Almeraq in a field of 19.

Kalpana, the Hardwicke Stakes
An Exchange SP of 3.35, traded down to 1.54 in running, then beaten 0.1 lengths by Giavellotto in a field of 12.

Endorsement, the Hampton Court Stakes
An Exchange SP of 2.48, traded down to 2.08 in running, then beaten 1.0 lengths by Generic in a field of 10.

Sun Goddess, the Albany Stakes
An Exchange SP of 2.04, traded down to 1.69 in running, then beaten 1.0 lengths by Libertango in a field of 25.

Others that have traded odds-on and still been beaten
Adaay Of Scarlett is the one that still stings. A Group 2 at Goodwood, an Exchange starting price of 13, and he traded at 1.02 before Man's Best Friend got back up. We had written that it looked like the day he finally got his moment. It was not.

French Duke is the most expensive. York, 21 August, a heritage handicap worth over £61,000 to the winner. He traded 1.22 having started at better than 20 on the Exchange, and was beaten 0.05 lengths, a nose, in a field of 17.

Dubai Champion, an 18 runner nursery at Goodwood, traded 1.07 and was beaten 0.1 lengths by Revels, who came down the far side.

Trawlerman, twice
Trawlerman is the one horse on this list who is here twice, and the 2 runs could hardly be less alike. He was beaten 0.2 lengths by Scandinavia in the Gold Cup after trading 1.27. We wrote before the Goodwood Cup 5 weeks later that he would reverse that form with the same horse, with the fitness excuse now gone.

He did not. Scandinavia beat him 8 and a half lengths. Being 2nd twice sounds like 2 near misses, and in this case only one of them was.
Three more that were odds-on and beaten
Misterdoc traded 1.25 at Newton Abbot and was done by Intellotto, a horse ridden with more patience.

Adrestia traded 1.34 at Doncaster in a 16 runner handicap and was beaten 0.2 lengths by Ancient State.

Great Barrier Reef traded 1.44 at the Curragh and was beaten 0.3 lengths.

The bigger prices
Everything above went odds-on in running, which is its own kind of frustrating. This next lot is the other sort: horses we put up at a proper price that ran into 2nd. Some of them got close and some of them did not, but every one of them was a day where we found the right horse at a price and still came away with nothing. Biggest price first.
Manatee Mehmas at 15.33
A 19 runner heritage handicap over 5f, York, 19 August. An Exchange SP of 15.33, a low of 2.50 in running, beaten 1.25 lengths by Miss Yechance in a field of 19. We had put him up on a first time tongue strap, and the strap did its job. The horse just could not get past.

Rhapsody at 13.50
A Listed race for fillies and mares, York, 20 August. An Exchange SP of 13.50, a low of 5.50 in running, beaten 3.25 lengths by Prizeland in a field of 15. We thought she had finally been given the trip she wanted. She ran well and she was still well held.

Hopewell Rock at 10.50
The Ebor, worth £300,000 to the winner, York, 22 August. An Exchange SP of 10.50, a low of 2.02 in running, beaten 0.2 lengths by Daiquiri Bay in a field of 24. This is the one that hurt most. We had been on him all season and said so in print every time. A 24 runner Ebor, a 10.50 chance of ours, and 0.2 lengths in it.

Katate Dori at 10.35
A 3m1f handicap chase, Cheltenham, 24 October. An Exchange SP of 10.35, a low of 2.04 in running, beaten 1.25 lengths by Here Comes Georgie in a field of 9. We wrote that off a mark 3lb lower he could run the same race he ran here on New Year's Day. He did, and it was not enough.

Geryon at 9.73
The Gordon Stakes, a Group 3, Goodwood, 30 July. An Exchange SP of 9.73, a low of 2.22 in running, beaten 1.25 lengths by Enceladus in a field of 7. Our line before the race was that he did not need to find a pound of improvement. He did not find one, and that turned out to be the problem.

Bullet Point at 8.00
The heritage handicap he had won 12 months earlier, York, 20 August. An Exchange SP of 8.00, a low of 4.70 in running, beaten 2.5 lengths by The Lost King in a field of 17. Back for the same race off 1lb higher than the day he won it. Second this time.

Lake Forest at 7.80
The City Of York Stakes, a Group 1, York, 22 August. An Exchange SP of 7.80, a low of 2.18 in running, beaten 2.75 lengths by Notable Speech in a field of 14. We argued he was underestimated at 7f against 2 rivals who wanted a mile. One of those rivals beat him.

The Hardest Geezer at 6.61
A conditional jockeys' handicap hurdle, Cheltenham, 23 October. An Exchange SP of 6.61, a low of 2.42 in running, beaten 4.5 lengths by Continuance in a field of 13. We said it was all about whether he was fit after 8 months off. On this evidence he was not, quite.

Moonfall at 5.40
The Challenge Cup, Ascot, 3 October. An Exchange SP of 5.40, a low of 2.80 in running, beaten 0.2 lengths by Mezcala in a field of 18. An 18 runner heritage handicap, and 0.2 lengths in it at the line.

Indian River at 4.70
The Masterson Holdings Hurdle, Cheltenham, 24 October. An Exchange SP of 4.70, a low of 2.02 in running, beaten 7 lengths by North Shore in a field of 7. In the interest of being straight about it, this one was not close. He was 2nd and he was beaten 7 lengths.

What we take from it
The honest reading first. Every one of those seconds is a race we did not win, and no amount of context changes that.
The second reading is the one we think matters more. Nineteen of them were odds-on in running and 7 were beaten by a nose or a short head. That is not a record of picking the wrong horse. It is a record of picking a horse that was going to win and then watching the last half furlong go the other way. Over a longer run those races split differently.
The third reading is the useful one, and it is about rides rather than ratings. East India Express hit the front and got caught. Misterdoc was in front and got done by a horse ridden with more patience. Satono Reve, Gstaad and Kalpana were all headed inside the final strides. When our horse is the one making its move first and getting picked off, that is a trend worth watching, and it is the thing we will keep writing about.
What we want from the next 3 or 4 months
Simple enough: we want these to turn into winners. Not better seconds, not closer seconds. Winners, and ideally some of them at the sort of prices that were in this piece. A 21.00 shot going odds-on in running and getting touched off is a near miss; a 21.00 shot going odds-on and holding on is a very different afternoon.
And the pattern has come straight into the National Hunt season with us. Over one weekend at Cheltenham we were 2nd with East India Express, 2nd with Katate Dori and 2nd with Indian River. Three more, in 2 days, at the start of a brand new campaign.
So the target for the winter is a boring one to write down and a hard one to do. Fewer seconds than winners by the spring.
